Google now offers a Search Console control that lets publishers exclude their content from its AI features. It follows the UK Competition and Markets Authority’s first conduct requirement on Google, imposed over the summer. Google opened the control to sites worldwide on August 31. Digiday reported on 9 November that publishers are holding off on using it until Google hands over click data. UK publishers are due that data by December 3.
At the same time, Google is making AI Overviews and AI Mode more prominent. It shows links more often, adds article carousels and is testing links from publisher names to their Search profiles.
Publishers can’t decide because the data is missing
Google has shared impression data, which shows how often a publisher’s content appears in AI features. It has held back click data. Chris Dicker, CEO of Candr Media, told Digiday that click data “is the metric that will determine whether they turn it off or not.”
The controls are also bundled. A publisher can’t opt out of one feature without opting out of the rest. The Professional Publishers Association is asking the CMA to require per-feature controls. David Buttle of SPUR expects Google to send enough referral traffic that publishers stay in voluntarily.
What changed and what didn’t
A publisher can now choose to leave Google’s AI answers. That is new, and it is a real choice for a company whose revenue is a click on an article.
The incentives didn’t change. Google still holds the audience, and a publisher that opts out has to ask whether it wants to be absent from the places users are. Carly Steven at the Daily Mail raised that question. Josh Muncke at The Economist Group said the decision depends on Google traffic and on how often the company’s name appears in AI answers. He described it as testing and measuring over time, not one in-or-out call.
That last point is the useful one. Even the publishers think in terms of being named.
An operator should treat opting out as a cost
Most of my readers don’t run a newsroom. Think of a physiotherapy clinic, a coffee roaster or a marketing team at a software company. You don’t earn money from the page view. You earn it when someone asks an AI “who should I use” and your name is in the answer.
For you, opt-out is a different decision from the publisher’s. A publisher is protecting content that others are using. You are trying to be used. If you excluded your pages from Google’s AI features, you would be removing yourself from the place where buyers now get their shortlist.
Ranking is dead as the goal. A page-one position on Google doesn’t mean much when answers come from a wider set of engines and clicks have collapsed. On stridec.com, non-branded positions 1 to 3 got a 0.08% click-through rate from June to August 2026. Being named in the answer is the outcome.
Put the effort into being quotable, and date your measurements
The AI doesn’t pick the biggest brand. It picks the one it understands most clearly and can quote most precisely. You can work on that.
Write down exactly what you are, who you serve and what is different about you. Use numbers and plain facts, because engines quote specific facts and drop adjectives. When I did this for AeroChat, Google’s AI Overview was citing it alongside Tidio and Intercom within three weeks of launch.
Then measure. Check whether you are named, not only whether you rank. Ranking and being named are separate, so find out which one is broken before you fix anything. Date every result, because AI answers change week to week.
Muncke’s point applies to you too. One check proves little. A series of dated checks shows whether your name is appearing more or less often.
What I would do this week
- Pick the five questions a buyer asks before choosing someone like you. Run them in Google’s AI Overviews, AI Mode and ChatGPT. Record the date and whether you were named.
- Read what those answers say about you. If the description is vague or wrong, fix the pages you control so they state what you are in specific terms.
- Leave the opt-out control alone unless you have a publisher’s reason, such as content that others resell. Revisit it only if your own measurements show that being in AI answers brings you nothing.
- Repeat the check every month and keep the log.